Kindly click here to download the full report on Macroeconomic Update 2023 Q2. Below is the summary:
Review of the Global Economy
Global GDP growth remains sluggish due to slower growth of consumer demand
Data Source: International Monetary Fund (IMF)
Oil price heads towards US$100 per barrel as Saudi Arabia and Russia cut production
Data Source: EIU
Analyst Views on the Global Economy
•The Russia-Ukraine war continues to restrain the global supply-chain, with negative implication of regional and global output growth and inflation. Although inflation rate appears to be trending downwards in developed economies, many emerging and developing countries are still dealing with high prices and the implication of high interest rates. The continuation of the war will be a major risks to global growth and inflation in the near term.
•Upward trending oil price driven by voluntary cuts by Russia and Saudi Arabia could elevate inflationary pressure in developed countries. This, therefore, could result in a higher interest rate environment as Central Banks are likely to keep benchmark rates stable in the short term. For developing economies, this will impact capital flows unfavourably and could slow down output growth.
•The invitation of Argentina, Egypt, Ethiopia, Iran, Saudi Arabia and the UAE to join the BRICS countries in January 2024 highlights the increasing dominance of the East in global economic affairs. The group represents a larger share of the world’s population and GDP. With more countries expressing interest to join the group, the world could be heading towards a shift in the global order.
•In the first quarter of 2023, there were fears of a banking crisis following the collapse of SVB and other banks. The investigation report of the committee set up by President Joe Biden revealed that the collapse of SVB was due to internal mismanagement and supervisory missteps. While the fear of a banking crisis has been doused, banking regulators need to be vigilant and ensure tight and effective supervision, as the world cannot afford a global banking crisis at this moment. The Central Bank of Nigeria must continue to risk-assess Nigerian banks and ensure compliance with relevant guidelines.
Nigeria’s Macroeconomic Environment
Nigeria’s real GDP growth of 2.5% for 2023Q2 remains weak and was driven by the non-oil sector
Data Source: National Bureau of Statistics
In Q2, 11 sectors experienced a higher output relative to Q1. Crude oil theft continues to weigh on oil output and growth of the mining & quarrying sector
Data Source: National Bureau of Statistics
Inflation rate rose to 25.8% in August 2023 reflecting the impact of fuel subsidy removal
Data Source: National Bureau of Statistics
•Since the subsidy removal, inflation rate has edged up by 3.4 percentage points. Food inflation rate rose faster to 29.3% in August.
•Further increase in petrol and diesel prices as well as exchange rate depreciation are likely to drive up inflation rate in coming months.
Since the assumption of office by President Tinubu, the Government has shown commitment to implement foreign exchange reforms…
External Reserves trended downwards as CBN continued its intervention in the I&E window
The pressure on external reserves is largely as a result of: 1. High demand for foreign currency to meet goods imports and service payments. 2. Limited investment inflows due to weak confidence. 3. Limited inflows from crude oil sales due to oil theft.
Clearly, Nigeria does not have the luxury to defend the Naira. Therefore, further exchange rate depreciation should be expected in the coming months.
JP Morgan estimated Nigeria’s External Reserves at US$3.7 billion
Data Source: JPMorgan Chase & Co.
Going by JP Morgan estimates, Nigeria’s External Reserves could only cover less than one month of imports of goods and services
Data Source: CBN, NBS, In-house computation
Analyst Views on Growth and Inflation
GDP Growth
Nigeria’s GDP growth is expected to be lower than 3% in 2023. The lower growth projection is driven by weak oil production volumes, high inflation which has weakened consumer demand and the FX depreciation. Already as at Q2, financial books of large corporates in the manufacturing sector have shown significant losses due to exchange rate depreciation. We expect this trend to continue for the rest of the year. Large corporates are also expected to devise strategies to cope with the exchange rate adjustments.
Inflation
The removal of fuel subsidy drove up prices of food and other items. With oil price approaching US$100 pb, there is the possibility of further increase in petrol prices in Q3 and Q4. Alternatively, the government will have to re-introduce subsidies in order to prevent further increase in petrol price. This scenario is likely, although, the amount spent on subsidies is expected to remain far below what was obtainable in the previous administration. Other factors such as infrastructure deficit, supply chain bottlenecks, port charges, etc. are still evident and will continue to drive up prices in the medium term.
Analyst Views on FX and Reserves
Forex and Reserves
Despite the exchange rate unification, FX inflows into Nigeria are lagging. On the other hand, the demand for foreign currency remains high thereby creating pressure on the exchange rate. In addition, limited access to FX in the official market (delays, backlogs, documentation requirements) are incentivizing players to purchase FX in the black market.
On a positive note, the government removed the peg on the official exchange rate in June 2023. This suggests some level of commitment to exchange rate reforms. The President is also at the forefront of wooing investors with the Nigeria-India Business Summit as an example. To win back investor’s confidence, we believe that the government must intensify its efforts in curtailing oil theft in the short term and provide a clear roadmap to improve FX inflows and management in the medium to long term to assure top institutional investors. In the immediate term, we expect the Naira to continue to face pressure in the official market.
Fiscal and Monetary Policy Update
Upward trending crude oil price raises concerns on the sustainability of fuel subsidy removal
Data Source: EIU, NBS
•With crude oil price approaching US$100 per barrel, fuel subsidies are likely to return in order to prevent further increase in the price of petrol.
Public Debt debt stock rises to N87.4 trillion (US$113.4 billion) in June 2023
Data Source: Debt Management Office, World Bank
•The Debt Management Office recently included the N22.7 trillion ways and means in the country’s public debt stock for June 2023. Actual figures in June (N87.4 trillion) exceeded the DMO’s initial projection of N77 trillion earlier in the year.
•According to the World Bank estimates, with fuel subsidy removal, debt servicing is expected to reach a peak of 120% of revenue in 2023 and trend downwards thereafter. Fiscal gains from subsidy removal and FX reforms will be more visible in 2024 and 2025.
Analyst Views and Outlook on Fiscal Policy
The removal of fuel subsidies and FX reforms will improve government finances: The government has been the major beneficiary of these twin reforms of subsidy and FX. Inflow into the FAAC account has increased from about N800 billion monthly to over N1.7 trillion since the implementation of both reforms. This higher inflow will improve fiscal deficit and debt sustainability ratio in the short term. It could also slow down the pace of debt accumulation in Q3 and Q4 of 2023. In a scenario where subsidy returns, we believe the subsidy payments are likely to be lower than what was paid in the previous administration, especially as a significant part of the price burden has been transferred to households and businesses at fuel pumps. However, the return of subsidies will raise concerns from private sector players, particularly potential investors in the midstream oil and gas industry, and this could slow investment in the sector.
Government effectiveness: How and what these fiscal gains will be spent on are major areas of concern. This is partly because the government has yet to embark on any major budget reform. Such reforms could begin in Q4, when the preparation of the 2024 budget will commence. With the significant growth in government revenue, a N30 trillion 2024 budget will not be surprising. However, we expect to see the prioritisation of capital projects in the budget and key sectors like education and health care.
The high cost of governance remains a pending issue that needs to be resolved. With an average of 20.9% of actual FGN budget expenditures allocated to capital projects in the last two years, it is imperative for the new administration to prioritise budgetary reforms. The government must reduce the over-bloated cost of governance – particularly overheads and transfers – to ensure enough funds are available for infrastructure and other development purposes. In addition, there must be significant efforts to block leakages and ensure transparency of government finances in the new administration.
Key tasks awaiting the new CBN Governor
Analyst Views and Outlook on Monetary Policy
A slowdown in rate hike expected
For the first time since the rate hike began in May 2022, the CBN MPC, in July 2023, raised the MPR at a slower pace by 0.25 percentage points. Interestingly, looking at the voting patterns of the MPC members, 6 members voted to raise the MPR, while 5 members voted to hold the MPR. This suggests that more MPC members are tilting towards a hold, following the limited effectiveness of the MPR in curtailing inflation.
With this and ahead of the MPC meeting in September 2023, we expect the MPC to either hold or raise rates by a smaller magnitude to 19%. We believe a raise is more likely.
A new CBN Governor is on the way
With the nomination of Mr Yemi Cardoso as the new CBN Governor, investors and other stakeholders will look forward to how the CBN will be managed and repositioned to achieve key goals of price stability, exchange rate and financial stability. Key areas of interest will include the CBN Governor’s views towards interest rate management, exchange rate management, cryptocurrency, the true position of the reserves and the apex bank’s role in financing government (Ways & Means) and development financing.
Currently, very little can be said about the proposed Governor’s position on these issues. However, we expect to see a pragmatic and engaging CBN Governor who will work to win the confidence of investors and other stakeholders.
Nigeria Market Update
Equity market has sustained positive trajectory since May 29
Data Source: NGX, CBN Note: End period for the data is September 15, 2023
Analyst Views and Outlook
Reforms and Policy signals
The President has also outlined 8 priorities to improve social and economic outcomes
In 2023Q1, we highlighted four key priorities for the new administration to implement to deliver an inclusive economy
At the core of Nigeria’s exchange rate policies should be the need to instil confidence on the economy
Beyond FX reforms, the government will need to target rapid and consistent expansion of the real sector as well as improve social inclusion
Macroeconomic Projection for 2023 – 2024 for Nigeria